Creative Testing Methods for Better Ad Performance

Side-by-side A/B comparison of two ad creative versions used in creative testing
ANA
American Express Business Class
Digiday
The Drum
Inc. 5000 logo for America's fastest-growing private companies
Financial Times 500 logo in black and grey
Fast Company logo in black text
Forbes logo in black text transparent
Fortune Global 500 logo in black text

There is a common misconception in digital advertising that a successful digital ad campaign begins with a perfect ad. Actually, successful campaigns are not usually based on one creative. They develop by testing, learning, and continual refinement.

Consumer behaviour is constantly evolving. The best ad of the day is not necessarily the best ad of the year, so wise advertisers never assume that they have the “perfect” ad. Rather, they test creatively to gain insight into what drives their audience and act on the real performance, not assumptions.

Every campaign provides an opportunity to learn more about performance, and with creative testing incorporated into your ROAS optimization efforts, you’ll have an opportunity to learn more.

Test Your Best Ideas

After investing time in the creative concept, it’s easy to fall in love with it. But consumers don’t always react as marketers hope. With different methods of testing, it can be found out that the simplest of all ads is the best compared to the ad that everyone thought would win.

Designer comparing shoe ad creative variations on screen to test the best ideas

Experiment With Small Details

It is not always necessary to revamp a whole campaign to yield better results. The headline, product image, and the opening sentence can influence the way a user will respond to an ad. Little bits of improvement can add up to big improvements over time.

Ad layout on a monitor highlighting small details such as the headline, product image, and feature icons

Watch How People Respond

The data from the campaigns speaks for itself and does not require creative opinions. By analysing engagement rates, click-through rates, conversion information, and user behaviour, advertisers can gain insights into what works and what doesn’t in their creatives.

Marketer reviewing an ad campaign dashboard to see how people respond to the creative

Build on What Works

It’s not creative testing to be constantly changing those ads that work. After you find messaging that works, leverage that information to develop new messaging variations while keeping what works. This way, campaigns can be kept fresh without having to begin from scratch.

A winning ad creative branching into new variations to build on what works

Keep Learning Every Campaign

Each campaign provides fresh insights into your audience. The outcomes of a creative will influence future ad decisions in the case of poor or good performance. The advertisers who continue to do well are those who view each campaign as a learning experience.

Analyst studying a campaign performance dashboard to keep learning from every campaign

Creative Testing Methods for Better Ad Performance

Looking to make your campaign better?

The best advertisers aren’t winging it; they’re making decisions based on what they know by testing and optimizing continuously. Each experiment offers insights that can help with making better advertising choices for the next time.

Brill Media supports businesses in creating creative strategies based on data to help optimize campaign performance and drive long-term ROI across digital ads.

Start Now

Brill Media helping a business improve ad performance through creative testing

Supercharge your performance media buying 🚀

Contact

(800) 488-1973

hello@brillmedia.co

16133 Ventura Blvd, Suite 700
Encino, CA 91436